Boots    Best of Index   Articles    Editorials    Interviews    Reviews



From REG #19

A video Review
by Michael Simone

few years ago, the Pink Floyd collectors community was surprised and amazed by the existence of an entire performance of The Wall by Pink Floyd on video.
Reviewed in REG # 6, this video was a dream come true for the millions of fans who were not lucky enough to be able to travel the hundreds or thousands of miles to the few cities in which Pink Floyd performed The Wall during the 1980 and 1981 tours. Because of the animosity which existed between Dave and Roger, and Roger owning all rights to any video's, it was thought it that a video would never be made available.

When this video came out it caused quite a stir among Floyd and Waters fans, and with Roger Waters himself. For this video was not the typical bootleg video shot from a hidden stationary hand held camera, and shot from somewhere in the audience at the back of an auditorium. There was no camera jitter and movement, no low quality shots, no splicing or flickering evident. It was clear that this video was somewhat professionally done, and that the film was shot from three separate angles, with three separate cameras with professional pan and zoom features, and on tripods. These films are definitely professionally edited! It was obvious the photographers recording this event had the Floyd's permission. It is known that only Roger Waters has all rights and access to any and all video's shot during The Wall concerts, and he had heretofore refused to release any footage of the events. Therefore Roger was quite aroused and upset at the prospect of bootleggers getting a hold of any tapes of these shows.

It is known that Pink Floyd in cooperation with Alan Parker, had had professionals video tape all The Wall concerts so that bits and pieces might be used as added segments in the motion picture of The Wall, which was at the time, in the process of being made.

However, apparently, the road crew had gained permission to also film a few of these shows as well. And it was from three tripod's around the stage and in the mixing booth hand professional hand held cameras that these shows were filmed. It is believed that this is the source of both the Nassau and the Earls Court videos.

But, because the video tapes being sold were so many generations from the original, they such poor quality, that when Roger saw a copy I don't think he was quite as upset.

This video, again is believed to be another of the video's which were filmed by the road crew. Where the other available bootleg was filmed at the Nassau Coliseum in New York, this is a better concert, and filmed at Earls Court in London. This show is most likely the August 9, 1980 show, since it is the only show where Roger introduces "Run Like Hell" three times.

I was warned not to be too critical of this video. I was told that there had been an extreme effort to keep this video from getting into the hands of fans and collectors. Apparently they had purposefully glitched parts of the video so as to discourage copying. This would account for the pervasive audio dropouts during show. However another copy was located and together a complete and watchable concert was made. So, though this film is still extremely lacking in quality, this is truly a much better bootleg in quality than the Nassau concert, and the show is a much better show. In this video, the color is not as washed out, nor are the images as blurry as the Nassau show, and though the audio drop outs become extremely!!! annoying, as in both these video's the audio track is clearly and obviously taken from the mixer.

The spectacular notability of these videos is that in this day and age, with Roger is off on his own, and Dave is thinking he is Pink Floyd, a great many Pink Floyd fans were not even alive when these concerts were performed. Vast numbers of Floyd fans have never had the opportunity to see the real Pink Floyd on stage or even who the real Pink Floyd is supposed to be.

Roger has said in the past, that he wants to perform The Wall for it's 20th anniversary, in the year 2000. Perhaps the celebration of this event will prompt him to release a professional video of the many Wall shows he owns the rights to. What a wonderful way to celebrate the 20th anniversary of The Wall, and what a wonderful gift that would be to his fans.

The Wall Live at Earls Court video begins with the announcer's "well I think we're about ready to begin," as the band launches into "In The Flesh". As I said earlier, this video, like most bootleg video's it is stepped on, or copied many generations from the original. This means that the colors are washed out, the images are unclear or fuzzy. And in this video, at least during the first third of the concert, the sound drops out regularly, as do sometimes even the film shots themselves. This quickly becomes more than an intolerable annoyance. At the end of "In the Flesh," the World War II Bomber comes gliding down over the crowd to crash into the back of the stage. And the band begins "The Thin Ice". Which of course is great. "Another Brick in the Wall Part 1," "The Happiest Days of Our Lives," and "Another Brick in the Wall Part 2," seem to go on much much longer than on the album, or even the live audio boot shows I remember listening to. There are some great shots of the inflatable Teacher puppet, and the Scarfe animations projected on the round screen.

As Roger plays "Mother" it hits me how much this is the real Pink Floyd, the Pink Floyd of old, and how much I miss them. There is nothing like seeing and hearing these four musicians together once more. Listening to The Wall, is fantastic enough but watching it, theatrically in concert becomes addictive forcing you to sit on the edge of your seat staring into the tube.

Though today, Roger does not show is age very much, this can not be said of Gilmour. In the video Dave looks so young. Maybe it's me that's getting old, maybe it's hard to remember them so young.

"Goodbye Blue Sky" is played, the video partially obscured by the skeletal rails erected in front of the band to hold the bricks of the wall. The bricks are slowly being laid, building the wall already high on both sides of the stage. Rick plays his fantastic layered keyboards encased and surrounded by swaths of keys. "What Shall We Do Now" and "Empty Spaces" is played. After which Roger says "Thank You, Good Evening."

All during the songs we see some really great close up shots of Dave and Roger. Young Lust is played, with a very unwelcome funky style lead organ played by Surrogate band keyboardist Peter Wood. He would have ruined the song were it not for seeing Roger and David share the same microphone inches away from one another. Enough of the fucking funky organ already. Peter Wood should have been thrown off the stage and escorted out of the auditorium. He is not part of Pink Floyd and if he is going to add his un-Floyd like fucked up funky style he's going to ruin the sound!

"One of My Turns" is played, Roger is singing in front of the wall, with the Wife puppet hovering over him above the wall as it fully inflates and moves ominously forward.

Roger breaks down in front of the wall singing "Don't Leave Me Now." The theatrics and his acting ability show his passion, as he makes you feel his anguish as his heart is breaking. Then as he gets angry from the rejection, and sings, "Another Brick in the Wall Part 3."

Watching the show, it is quite evident how each song is another chapter in the story of Pink's life. Having listened to The Wall for so many years I know the story well, but watching it like a stage play, performed by Pink Floyd before my eyes, it becomes much more apparent and real. Visually, the story becomes more readily comprehensible and understandable, more cohesive.

The last brick is laid in the wall, as Roger sings "Goodbye Cruel World." Then a 20 minute break is announced. The video then proceeds to the next song, which is "Hey You." The Wall now completely blocks off the band from the audience. Throughout the song all that is seen is a spot lit 'Pink" doll sitting on a brick in front of and at the bottom of the wall. Roger and David singing to the audience outside the wall. The theater is completely dark, as Roger sings "Is There Anybody Out There." Then a spotlight shines on a small hole in the wall at David as he plays the acoustic guitar solo. After this we only see the light of a small black and white TV as Rick's piano begins "Nobody home," and we see a small hotel room which has been opened up from inside the side of the wall.

After the song, the TV continues, a war movie is on, and "Vera" is played, as Roger sings, a picture of Vera Lynn is projected upon the Wall as are other photos. Then "Bring the Boys Back Home" is played and more photos of the troupes are projected upon the wall. Then we see the fist use of the three simultaneous films across the wall (later seen in The Pros and Cons shows) as "Comfortably Numb" begins. Gerald Scarfe drawings are flashing in three separate sequences, finally resolving into one. Dave sings and plays his guitar leads from the top of the wall as Roger, dressed as a doctor, sings to the wall at the bottom of the stage.

Again, the theater is dark except for the top of the circular screen seen above the wall, as "The Show Must Go On" is played. Nothing is seen by the audience, as the wall still blocks everything. Then again, Gary Yudman, the master of ceremonies comes on and makes the same various announcements that he made at the beginning of the show only in more or less slow motion. While he is doing this Pink Floyd and the Surrogate band are getting into position in front of the wall for the Nuremberg like scene of "In The Flesh."

One thing about this video, is that all audience noise is rarely even heard, thanks of course to the sound being taken from the mixing board. "In The Flesh" is played, as the entire wall lights up with crossed hammer graphics and all the stage personal and band in their respective uniforms. Roger, sings in his black storm trooper uniform and armband, as the huge Pig inflatable circles the crowd with it's spotlight eyes. At the end Roger says, "Thankyou," tunes his bass a bit, then asks the audience if they like the pig, as the sound drops out again. He says "he's and old pig but he's a big pig. The audience cheers, then Roger says, "here's a song for all you paranoids in the audience, it's called "Run Like Hell," and screams "run like hell, run like hell." As the song is played it's great watching Dave and Roger trade off vocals. The Surrogate band stands off to each side of each of the other members. Roger is jamming and plays his bass like a lead guitar, obviously having fun. There are really some great close ups during this song.

At the end of the song Roger says "Thankyou, we always like to do something for the disco fans. Then "Waiting for the Worms" begins. Roger plays the perfect fascist leader. At the end we see a long shot from the mixing station as Scarfe's marching hammers march across the huge wall backdrop. Then all the light is extinguished and the 'Pink' doll in front of the wall is again spotlighted as Roger sings "Stop".

Now most of the bands equipment has been cleared from in front of the stage as "The Trial" begins, and again the wall is used for the Scarfe trial animation. All the band is again behind the wall, with Roger singing the various voices of prosecutor, teacher, judge, mother, and wife. The wall finally comes down at the end in a stunning and spectacular conclusion of smoke, lighting, and strobe light effects.

Then the 'troupe' of musicians and singers, Floyd and surrogate band, stroll out on stage with acoustic instruments, and in front of the demolished wall play "Outside the Wall." Roger leads them on an off stage playing the clarinet. It is only once for minute when you hear the crowd in it's full sound in a tremendous applause, and not dampened by the mixer. After the 'bleeding hearts troupe leaves the stage, Pink Floyd strolls out one last time to take a bow. Roger says, "Thankyou" and they leave the stage. The lights come on in Earls Court and the audience begins to leave to the tune of "American Patrol" piped in through the PA.

The film ends. What a concert. What an event. I certainly wish I had been lucky enough to have been there, or seen any of The Wall shows. As I said in the review of the Nassau show, I was working in a record store at the time, south of San Francisco, and my boss went down to LA to see the show leaving me to mind the store. If I had known then what I had missed, I probably would have quit my job, and done anything to attend.

This video, like the other, is a true collectors item, but is not just a commemorative piece of history. Watching these concerts is like watching theater, a play or movie. Like watching the album come to life. It is a visual experience not to be missed. Yet, it's sad the quality is so poor. This would have been a great show for Pink Floyd to have released professionally on video. Maybe Roger will think about releasing a better version in another few years.


   Boots    Best of Index   Articles    Editorials    Interviews    Reviews